Have been meaning to post this since it was released, but I have no organisation. Anyway, now it sees the light of day.
Music review | Eminem - Encore [2004]
Between each of his albums, Eminem has advanced as an artist and matured as a human being. The skittish, brash toilet humour of his ‘99 debut, The Slim Shady LP (public debut - discounting the EP and Infinite) was replaced by brooding menace in his self-titled sequel released in September the following year. In The Eminem Show, released in 2002, Eminem had all but left aside true menace for cartoon-esque capers, with the launch single Without Me all but underlining his new intent: to parody himself and anyone who got in his way, alongside verbalising his ever-compelling life story. The album also marked a significant advance in rapping ability, with Mathers taking on lyrics that were hard-hitting attacks on specific issues as well as rapid-fire seek-and-destroy missions on electic targets-of-opportunity.
Whilst it may seem like a predictable cash-in on The Eminem Show en lui of its title and cover art (the often made assumption that it’s easy for the rapper to pen new lyrics around old ground) Marshall Mather’s fourth album proper is anything but. Where in the first two releases he focused on attack and destruction, developed here is The Eminem Show tactic of inciteful commentary. Those looking for controversy will find less than before, then, but this tempered aggression easily makes Encore his most mature and articulate musical offering yet, and put simply this is why true Eminem fans will hang on every multisyllabic cuss, joke and reminisce.
Short of a track-by-track rundown, I’ll mention a few of the stand-outs. It’s worth noting that the album is perfectly listenable from end to end, even though there are favourites which will inevitably get replayed along the way. One such track is the opener, Evil Seed. It’s not dissimilar to Cleaning Out My Closet in its references to his estranged mother (and all the other songs focusing on that issue), and for a minute you’re anxious that this is a retread over familiar ground. That assertion is quickly dealt with as Eminem unveils a startlingly new freeform style, the playground-style repetition of each line end instantly transporting us back to his childhood. So whilst the content is familiar, the performance is not, and this elevates the content above all previous efforts.
“Predominantly, predominantly, everything’s always predominantly
Predominantly white, predominantly black, but what about me
where does that leave me? Well I guess that I’m between predominantly
both of ‘em, I think if I hear that fuckin word again I’ma scream
– Evil Seed
Never Enough, Yellow Brick Road and Toy Soldiers cover Eminem’s past and present controversies, like Benzino and the Source tape - elloquent words over bittersweet melodies (the sampling of Martika’s Toy Soldiers could have been corny, but it serves up a suitably poingnant sound) but Mathers is careful not to exaggerate events or his own persona, and if there is one style at the core of Encore, then that is it - it’s a personal album with as little hubris as possible. It’s true that a large part of Eminem’s appeal was/is his larger-than-life characters - be it Shady or Mathers or Eminem - but it’s equally true that because of all the front fans never really got to hear the true voice. Whilst there is a lot of style and performance left on display in later tracks, the words seem picked for accuracy and effect as well as thrills.
“There used to be a time when, you could just say a rhyme and
wouldn’t have to worry about, one of your people dyin
But now it’s elevated, cause once you put someone’s kids in it
the shit gets escalated, it ain’t just words no more is it?”
– Like Toy Soldiers
Fastforward a little bit and there’s Rain Man, probably the funniest track committed to an album by Eminem, with a verse tackling the Christopher Reeves issue (apparently cursed due to Eminem’s behaviour waybackwhen), another that could be labled ‘What Does The Bible Say About Gay Sex?’, and a final scatter-gun verse that merges a lot more in-jokes in a suitably chaotic fashion. The chorus is a killer. Towards the end of the record we have another oddity Ass Like That a rap in the style of Triumph the Insult Comic Dog (a decent impression, too) for whatever reason.
“You find me offensive; I find you offensive for finding me offensive
Hence if I should draw out or line any fences; if so
to what extents if any should I go? Cause it’s getting expensive
Being on the other side of the courtroom on the defensive”
– Rain Man
There are a couple of tracks that dip below par like the D-12 track One Shot to Shot notable for the absence of MC Proof, and thus the 5-star merit is not entirely justified. And elsewhere, the revisionist feeling is stronger than others when the lyrical content is not able to dazzle - as in Puke. But for the tracks that do stick it, fans are gifted another compelling and enjoyable look into the life of one of the most talented rappers currently making music. All but the most harsh critics will forgive a little repetition when it’s as consistently entertaining as this.
****